If the rent is no longer paid…

An insolvency administrator is personally liable if, after the estate has become insufficient, he fails to observe the priority order stipulated in Section 209 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) during distribution
. This is an interesting ruling for landlords.

We have achieved an important procedural success for our client with the judgment of the Freiburg Regional Court of 26 June 2025 (Case No. 11 O 152/22).

Our client was the landlord of the business premises of an insolvent company. We represented her in the case as her legal counsel.

Context of the decision:

The insolvency administrator had reported the insufficiency of assets in the month in which the terminated lease was due to end.

This is common practice. However, there had already been indications of insufficient assets some time before.

The rent remained unpaid for months even before the insolvency proceedings were initiated. During this period, other creditors of the estate were paid, but our client was not. The insolvency administrator did
not provide a reason for the non-payment.

Subsequently, he attempted to offset the claim with counterclaims, but this failed due to a prohibition on counterclaims stipulated in the lease agreement. Furthermore, the counterclaims had since become time-barred.

The verdict of the Freiburg Regional Court:

According to the regional court, the insolvency administrator
violated his insolvency law obligations and must pay damages.

The insolvency administrator must settle the liabilities of the estate as soon as they
become due.

If he cannot satisfy all outstanding liabilities of the estate, he must satisfy them proportionally.

He is not authorized to allocate the risk of insolvency to specific creditors of the estate (cf. BGH, judgment of 06.05.2004, IX ZR 48/03).

Although the insolvency administrator is not legally obligated
to report the insufficiency of assets at a specific time to protect the creditors of the estate, if he fails to observe the ranking of claims under Section 209 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) after the actual occurrence of the insufficiency of assets, he becomes personally liable for damages.

An error in the distribution of the insolvency estate constitutes a breach of an insolvency-related duty and gives rise to liability under Section 60 of the German Insolvency Code (BGH, Judgment of
October 21, 2010, IX ZR 220/09). The substantive ranking of claims under Section 209 Paragraph 1, Paragraph 2 No. 1 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) – notwithstanding the contrary wording of the law – must be applied even before notification (BGH, Decision of November 19, 2009, IX ZB 261/08).

Legal status of the creditors in the estate:

In enforcing our client's claims, we found that the insolvency code does not adequately protect creditors of the estate, even though they placed their trust in the insolvency administrator. The burden of proof proved to be a significant hurdle. However, in this specific case, we were able to convince the court.

In detail:

1. Liabilities of the estate expire after three years (general limitation period), insolvency claims after 30 years.

For this reason, the creditor in the estate should consider interrupting the statute of limitations if the proceedings are to last a long time, and especially if insolvency has been indicated.

2. Insolvency courts, based on experience, only grant access to files to creditors of the estate if a legitimate interest is demonstrated and substantiated, which is not always successful.

3. In many cases, the insolvency administrator's notification of insufficient assets is not justified. This makes it almost impossible for outsiders to ascertain what circumstances prompted the insolvency administrator to report the insufficient assets at that particular time. 

Experience shows that the timing coincides with the expiry of notice periods.

4. Some insolvency administrators do not provide information about the claims of the old creditors. 

A list of the (old) liabilities of the estate is not submitted to the insolvency court, making it impossible for outsiders or the court to find out the due dates and the amount of these claims. 

Very high liabilities of the estate can be an indication that the estate's insufficiency existed earlier. The creditor generally bears the burden of proof in this regard.

5. Section 61 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO) only provides limited protection for the landlord. The landlord must prove the amount of damage caused by a late termination of the lease
.

He must prove that, had the lease been terminated earlier, he would have found a replacement tenant for the specific period who would have paid at least the previous rent. This will generally be impossible, because a
landlord doesn't actively seek out a tenant, and a tenant is under no obligation as long as the lease remains in effect.

Decisions like these strengthen the rights of creditors favored under Section 209 Paragraph 1 No. 2 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO), such as landlords or employees.

Recommendation for practical application:

Creditors whose claims were not satisfied before the insolvency proceedings were initiated should observe the statute of limitations and secure evidence. If the insolvency report and the insolvency administrator's reports are not available
, we recommend promptly requesting access to the files from the insolvency court.

Newsletter

Always up -to -date information about relevant developments and decisions in terms of law.

*If you do not choose any of the above options, you will automatically receive newsletters from all categories.

*By submitting this registration, you agree to our privacy policy . 

Contact

Do you have a concern and want to get in touch with us? Write us an email and we will be happy to contact you immediately. 

Georgenstrasse 23
10117 Berlin

Telephone: 030/235024-0
Fax: 030/235024-99

Email: berlin@schrade-partner.de

Heinrich-von-Stephan-Straße 15
79100 Freiburg

Telephone: 0761/389469-0
Fax: 0761/389469-99
E-Mail: freiburg@schrade-partner.de

Maggistraße 5
78224 Singen

Telephone: 07731/59145-500
Fax: 07731/59145-510
E-Mail: Singen@schrade-partner.de

Schickhardtstraße 57
70199 Stuttgart

Telephone: 0761/389469-98
Fax: 0761/389469-99
Email: stuttgart@schrade-partner.de

Max-Planck-Straße 11
78052 Villingen-Schwenningen

Telephone: 07721/20626-0
Fax: 07721/20626-100
E-Mail: Villingen@schrade-partner.de