BAG: employer must comply with the obligation to provide information
In two decisions of December 20, 2022, the Federal Labor Court further developed its case law on the employer's obligation to refer with regard to existing vacation entitlements. This has an impact on the statute of limitations and the decay of vacation entitlements. Employers are now - also to protect their own interests - to act.
According to Section 7 Paragraph 3 of the Federal Vacation Act (BUrlG), unused vacation time expires if it is not taken within the current calendar year. An exception applies if the vacation could not be taken due to urgent operational or personal reasons. In this case, unless otherwise agreed, it expires on March 31st of the following year.
I.) Defenders of the employer
The regulation of Section 7 (3) BurlG on the question of the expiry or the transferability of vacation entitlement beyond the current calendar year has been the subject of procedures before the European Court of Justice (ECJ) and the Federal Labor Court (BAG) in recent years. By decisions from 2019, the BAG - following the case law of the ECJ - had already decided several times that the claim, at least on the statutory minimum leave, expires only if the employer has previously enabled the employee to exercise his vacation entitlement and the employee did not take the vacation out of freely. This was justified with a guideline -compliant interpretation of § 7 BurlG with Art. 7 of Directive 2003/88/EC.
In this context, the Federal Labor Court (BAG) has set high standards for employers. The employer must , specifically and with complete transparency , that employees are actually able to take their paid annual leave. This can be achieved, for example, by each employee individually at the beginning of a calendar year, in writing or by email, how many vacation days they are (still) entitled to in that calendar year, requesting them to apply for their leave in a timely manner sothat it can be taken within the current leave year, and informing them that the leave will be forfeitedif it is not taken in time. The employer must also inform employees, if applicable, whether any leave has been carried over from the previous year(s), how many days are involved, and when this leave expires (BAG, judgment of February 19, 2019 – Case No. 9 AZR 423/16).
Based on this judgment, it can be assumed that a general leaflet or an email that is aimed at all employees does not meet the requirements of the BAG. Rather, it will be necessary that each employee is informed individually, how much vacation he is entitled to and how this vacation expires. If the corresponding information has not been or not in the right form, the employee's vacation entitlement does not expire, but is continued in the following year.
II.) Consequences of omitted notification obligations regarding the statute of limitations and forfeiture of vacation entitlements
The Federal Labour Court (BAG) has further developed this case law on the employer's duty to provide information in two recent decisions dated 20 December 2022 (Case Nos. 9 AZR 266/20 and 9 AZR 245/19) with regard to the effects on the limitation period and the forfeiture of holiday entitlements.
While employers have often relied on the assumption that their employees' vacation entitlements expire after three years, recent case law from the Federal Labor Court (BAG) clarifies that vacation entitlements do not automatically expire after three years. Although an employee's statutory right to paid vacation is subject to a three-year limitation period, this period (§ 195 of the German Civil Code (BGB)) only begins at the end of the calendar year in which the employee has full knowledge of their vacation entitlement (§ 199 para. 1 BGB). In its rulings of December 20, 2022, the BAG considers this knowledge to be present only if the employer has properly fulfilled their duty to inform the employee, i.e., if the employer has previously informed the employee about their specific vacation entitlement and the applicable deadlines, and the employee has nevertheless chosen not to take the vacation.
The same now applies to the forfeiture of vacation entitlements in cases of continued incapacity for work. According to previous case law of the Federal Labour Court (BAG), statutory vacation entitlements automatically expired on March 31 of the second year following the incapacity for work (the "15-month period"). The Senate has further developed this case law in accordance with the requirements of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) based on the preliminary ruling of September 22, 2022 (C-518/20 and C-727/20).
According to this, the vacation entitlement continues to expire at the end of the 15-month period if the employee has been prevented from starting his vacation for health reasons until March 31 of March 31 of the second year of the second year. In this case, it does not matter whether the employer has complied with his participation because they could not have contributed to the use of the vacation. However, it is different if the employee initially worked in the holiday year before he has become unable to work due to illness. In this case constellation, too, the employer must have to put the employee in good time before entering the incapacity to work, actually taking his vacation. If the employer has not complied with his obligation to refer before the employee's incapacity to work in the calendar year in question, the vacation entitlement does not expire at the end of the 15-month period.
III.) Impact of current decisions and recommendations for action
The decisions of the BAG dated December 20, 2022 mean that claims for residual vacation or vacation compensation no longer expire without further ado after three years or, in the cases of long-term illness, cannot be easily assumed at the end of the 15-month period, but even years later-even after the employment relationship-even after the employment relationship-if a comprehensive and transparent information has not been made.
How these decisions will have an impact in practice, in particular also with regard to the models of trust working hours, in which workers can define their vacation more or less freely, cannot currently be assessed in conclusion. It will also be considered whether provisions for already expired or claims that have already been expired.
Employers are strongly advisedto inform all employees individually about their existing old and new vacation entitlements at the beginning of the coming calendar year and in all subsequent years, in accordance with the requirements of the Federal Labour Court (BAG).
Author and contact person:
