Law 16/2022 of September 5, 2022, fundamentally reformed Spanish insolvency law. This transposed Directive (EU) 2019/1023 of the European Parliament and of the Council of September 5, 2019, into Spanish law. The new Spanish Insolvency Code (Texto Refundido de la Ley Concursal) entered into force on September 26, 2022.
The reform aims to eliminate four structural disadvantages of Spanish insolvency law, namely the -previously- lack of a legal framework for restructuring outside of insolvency proceedings (comparable to the -German- procedure in StaRUG), the generally late filing of insolvency applications, the long duration of the insolvency proceedings and the low utilization of the debt discharge procedure.
Particularly in the regulation of debt discharge proceedings, the insolvency of so-called "micro-enterprises," and proceedings with limited assets, significant changes have been introduced that many creditors will feel the effects of. For "micro-enterprises," no insolvency administrator needs to be appointed—a development being discussed at the EU level as a solution for all member states.
1. Special procedure for micro-employment (from 01.01.2023), Art. 685 ff TRLC
According to the legal definition, microempresas are companies – including self-employed individuals – with fewer than 10 employees and either an annual turnover of less than EUR 700,000.00 or liabilities of less than EUR 350,000.00 according to the previous year's financial statements.
In Spain, as in Germany, the majority of companies fall into this category. The process has been significantly simplified and digitized (e.g., for filing applications or the free disposal of assets). The company's managing director bears a special responsibility in this process. An insolvency administrator is not appointed unless 20% (or 10% in the case of liquidation) of the creditors or the debtor request their appointment. In that case, the creditors or the debtor
would have to bear the costs of the insolvency administrator.
The debtor may, but is not obligated to, enter into negotiations with creditors prior to the proceedings. The aforementioned restructuring procedure is not applicable to micro-enterprises. In the insolvency petition, the debtor states whether the company is to be continued or liquidated. Continuation requires the submission of a continuation plan, which must be approved by the creditors. If liabilities to public creditors (e.g., tax office, social security institutions) reach 85% of the total liabilities, the company must be liquidated.
The application for liquidation can be made with or without transfer of the company.
A unique feature of the Spanish insolvency procedure is the classification of the insolvency proceedings as being caused by fault or not, which can have further consequences. Among other things, in cases of fault-based insolvency, debt discharge is denied.
2. Discharge of residual debt
Traditionally, the possibility of debt relief has been viewed critically in Spain. However, recent reforms have significantly simplified the process. Among other requirements, no relevant tax, social security, or property offenses have been convicted within the 10 years prior to the application, and the insolvency must not have been caused "through one's own fault" (Art. 487 TRLC). A new debt relief can be granted after two years (from the date of granting in the case of an installment payment agreement) or five years (from the date the decision becomes legally binding in the case of company liquidation). In Germany, the waiting period is 10 years. Public liabilities are not covered by a new application for debt relief (Art. 488 para. 2 TRLC).
Natural persons can apply for debt relief until shortly before the conclusion of insolvency proceedings. Consumers or self-employed individuals without business equipment do not need to file for insolvency; they can directly access the "Second Chance Law" (Ley de la segunda oporunidad), which is similar to debt relief proceedings. Their assets and income must be disclosed.
When applying for debt relief, the debtor has two options: either liquidating their assets or drawing up a payment plan with a duration of 3 years (5 years in special cases). With a payment plan, the assets (including the home) do not have to be liquidated.
However, creditors representing at least 5% of the liabilities can reject the plan and demand the liquidation of the debtor's assets if they are worse off under the payment plan than with liquidation.
The claims excluded from debt discharge are listed in Article 489 of the Cantonal Law. The discharge also covers liabilities of the estate and public debts, with one important limitation: the law sets a limit of EUR 10,000.00 per debtor for the discharge of tax liabilities and liabilities to social security institutions (Article 489 of the Cantonal Law). Public debts thus continue to be given priority.
3. The massless methods
If the debtor has no assets, the insolvency court opens insolvency proceedings after the debtor has disclosed their liabilities. Only if 5% of the creditors request it within 15 days of publication will an insolvency administrator be appointed. This administrator will examine, in particular, the existence of voidable transactions and the assertion of claims against the management. If no creditor requests it, insolvency proceedings can be concluded very quickly; debt discharge can be applied for within 10 days of the expiry of the aforementioned deadline and can also be obtained quickly if no creditor objects.
4. Outlook
The new (creditor-friendly) insolvency code already has a prominent restructuring case: the steel manufacturer Celsa. Here, creditors converted a portion of their claims into equity. The restructuring plan, approved by order of the Barcelona Commercial Court (Insolvency Court) 26/2023 of September 4, 2023, provided for a capital reduction to zero along with a capital increase (so-called "Operación acordeón"). The plan also included the exclusion of the existing shareholders' pre-emption rights. Certain creditors (foreign funds) will acquire the new shares at current market value by contributing their respective insolvency claims. Meanwhile, the authorities responsible for controlling foreign investments have approved the takeover under the following conditions: job preservation and the acquisition of 20% of the shares by a Spanish company. This precedent is expected to have far-reaching consequences. It is the first time in Spain that creditors have taken control of an insolvent company without the consent of the owners (shareholders).
The reform was expected to lead to an increase in insolvency filings, particularly for micro-enterprises and insolvent companies, since the appointment of an insolvency administrator is not mandatory. However, after a year, experience has shown that the special procedure for micro-enterprises – without the appointment of an insolvency administrator – is not being used. Only a very small number of applications have been filed. The reason for this is likely that business owners are uncertain and do not feel capable of taking on the responsibility of insolvency proceedings.
As a consequence, either regular insolvency proceedings or the special procedure for companies without assets is initiated. This could create a new area of expertise for lawyers, potentially to the detriment of the insolvency administrator profession. On the other hand, the number of insolvency proceedings without assets – and without an insolvency administrator – aimed at obtaining debt discharge has increased significantly. This primarily affects cases with low public-law liabilities.
The preferential treatment of such liabilities (tax office, social security institutions) can mean that individuals, especially those with failed businesses, see little advantage in initiating insolvency proceedings. If only a small proportion of public-law liabilities can be forgiven, the proceedings lose their appeal for these debtors.
In Germany, tax office claims and social security contributions are not given preferential treatment. However, if the debtor has committed an intentional tort, these liabilities are
not covered by debt discharge in Germany either. The European Directive assumes comprehensive debt discharge. For this reason, further reform in Spain cannot be ruled out.
Please note: This newsletter cannot replace individual consultation.
Your contact person for German-Spanish legal relations:
